dried parsley - getty

Source: Getty Images

London law firm Edwin Coe represented Camstar Herbs in a professional negligence claim against Advisory Insurance Brokers Limited, trading as Morgan Law Insurance Brokers

Dried parsley producer Camstar Herbs Limited has secured at least £2.4m in court-ordered payments after a factory fire exposed failings in its insurance cover.

London law firm Edwin Coe represented Camstar Herbs in a professional negligence claim against Advisory Insurance Brokers Limited, trading as Morgan Law Insurance Brokers. 

The High Court awarded Camstar the full £1.2m claimed in damages with interest, an additional award and an interim payment towards legal costs, bringing the current total to £2.4m.

Camstar had suffered from a fire in August 2021 at one of its processing facilities in Suffolk, which handled around 60% of its harvested parsley.

While the business had recovered substantial sums from its insurers, it was unable to recover payments it continued making to growers and its harvesting contractor, which were essential to “maintaining the supply relationships on which its future operations depended”.

The dispute arose after its broker recommended switching from a gross revenue business interruption policy to a cheaper insured profit (also known as a gross profit) policy in 2018, which saved just over £7,000 in annual premiums but did not cover these ongoing payments.

“After experiencing such a devastating fire, the last thing we expected was to discover that payments to some of our most important suppliers and harvesters weren’t covered by our insurance,” said Edward Starke, CEO and MD at Camstar. “These are relationships that are fundamental to our business, and we felt incredibly let down by the broker we had trusted to make sure we were properly protected.”

His Honour Judge Bird found the broker had breached its duty by recommending unsuitable insurance without explaining the difference in cover.

The Court also rejected the argument that the payments could have been recovered under the policy as an increased cost of working.

“This case should be a wake-up call for British manufacturers,” said Oliver Pannell, partner in the insurance disputes team at Edwin Coe. “A factory fire can stop production overnight, but it doesn’t mean a business can simply stop paying its suppliers and contractors. Those relationships may be essential to its survival.”

Coe said the judgement was “an important reminder that businesses and their brokers need to understand exactly what their insurance will cover if something goes wrong”.

The High Court refused the defendant permission to appeal.